
Frustrating potential.
Banished is the only title from solo-dev Shining Rock Software, LLC. https://shiningrocksoftware.com/ As far as I can tell, they have gone radio silent since April 2022. This is a shame, as I see a lot of potential evident in this game.
This game frustrates me every time I play it. Not because it’s difficult, but because it had the potential to be my kind of diversion. It’s no surprise that my bailiwick is resource management. Satisfactory, The Long Dark, Subnautica, Frostpunk, Timberborn, etc. I can’t say exactly why this kind of game appeals to me, but it is enough to say that it does.
Banished is unfinished, unpolished, unoptimized, and somewhat unimaginative. To my ken, there is one song in the game. It’s a fine song, and doesn’t feel oppressive or repetitive, but there is no variety. The buildings look authentic, and the animations are passable. There are plenty of resources to manage, just the right amount. The tech tree makes sense and is well-balanced, such that the gameplay loop keeps you wanting the “next thing”.
You feel forever on the brink of starvation, carefully balancing living space with limited food and fuel. That’s where the game shines. It keeps you thinking about it while you do the dishes and walk the dog. “Do I have another worker to make firewood? Would a market better cover that area?”
But this is also where the game’s shortcomings make me throw up my hands. Because this game is effectively abandoned, there are long-standing game-breaking run-ending bugs that will live forever in the back of my mind. As an example, when you finally set up a market, all of the fuel (firewood, coal) is brought to one central location, from which your population can take what they need. It’s one of the most meaningful upgrades in the game. And then one of your households takes all the fuel at once and the rest of the population freezes to death.
Hidden tripwires like this are not fun. If you don’t know where to look for them, they end your run. If you have a terribly stubborn personality like yours truly, you might start another playthrough, but more likely you’ll just play something that doesn’t punish you for not knowing that the dev didn’t patch a bug.
The Steam Workshop has some patches. Some enterprising people decided to build mods that transform the game completely into a colony sim. It’s worth a look if you decide to give Banished a shot. I don’t know if I would recommend paying the full $20, but it sometimes goes on sale for about $7.